Choosing between taking a personal loan vs savings depends on how much money you have saved, your monthly expenses, and the interest you will pay on a loan.
It is a good idea to keep enough savings to cover 3 to 6 months of essential living expenses for emergencies. If paying for a big expense leaves you with very little money, consider taking a Personal Loan or using both savings and a loan.
However, if your savings earn less interest than what you will pay on a personal loan, borrowing could cost you more in the long run. When evaluating borrowing vs saving money, compare both options to choose what best fits your budget, whether you are paying a medical bill, fixing your home, or managing a major life event.
What Are the Pros and Cons of Using Your Savings?
Pros
- No Interest or Extra Charges: You do not have to pay interest, processing fees, or charges for repaying a loan early.
- No Monthly EMIs: Without loan payments, you have more of your monthly salary available for everyday expenses and future savings.
- No Waiting for Approval: Your savings are available when you need them. There is no need for credit checks or lender approval.
Cons
- Less Money for Emergencies: Using up most of your savings can leave you short of money if an unexpected expense comes up.
- Missed Investment Earnings: If you take money out of investments or fixed deposits, you could miss out on the interest or returns they might have earned.
- Takes Time to Save Again: Building your savings back up after spending a large amount can take months or even years.
What Are the Pros and Cons of Taking a Personal Loan?
A personal loan preserves liquid cash for emergencies, but introduces a mandatory monthly liability with cumulative interest costs.
Pros
- Keeps Your Savings Aside: You can keep your emergency savings in your bank account or fixed deposits for unexpected expenses.
- Fixed Monthly EMIs: You pay a fixed EMI every month for the loan period. This makes it easier to plan your monthly budget.
- Can Improve Your Credit Score: Paying your EMIs on time can help improve your credit score over time.
Cons
- Interest Adds to the Cost: Personal loan interest rates may range from 11% to 18% per year, increasing the total amount you repay.
- Extra Charges: You may have to pay processing fees, documentation charges, and GST on applicable fees. Some charges may be deducted before the money reaches your account.
- Fixed Monthly Payments: Paying an EMI every month leaves you with less money for emergencies, other expenses, or savings.
What Should You Do? Use Savings or Take a Loan
You must be thinking “Should I use savings or take a loan?” Before deciding, look at how much money you have saved, how much the expense will cost, and how much money you will have left afterwards.
Scenario 1: You Have Enough Savings (Expense < 30% of Your Savings)
- The Situation: You have ₹10,00,000 in savings and need ₹2,50,000 for home renovation.
- The Math: If you pay in cash, you will still have ₹7,50,000 left. If this is enough to cover your living expenses and emergencies, you may not need to borrow. Taking a Personal Loan instead could mean paying ₹54,000 or more in interest.
- Best Choice: Use your savings.
- Why: You can pay for the renovation and still keep enough money aside for emergencies, without paying interest on a loan.
Scenario 2: Your Savings Are Limited (Expense > 70% of Your Savings)
- The Situation: You have ₹3,00,000 in savings, which is also your emergency money. You now have a medical bill of ₹2,00,000.
- The Math: Paying the full bill from your savings will leave you with just ₹1,00,000. This may not be enough if another emergency comes up. Taking a Personal Loan could mean paying an EMI of around ₹9,500 a month, depending on the loan terms.
- Best Choice: Consider a personal loan or a mix of savings and a loan.
- Why: Using most of your savings can leave you with very little money for future emergencies. If the monthly EMI fits comfortably into your budget, borrowing some of the amount could help you keep some savings aside.
Scenario 3: The Expense Uses Up All Your Savings
- The Situation: You have ₹1,50,000 in savings and need the same amount for an urgent major repair.
- The Math: Paying the full amount in cash will leave you with no savings. A Personal Loan could help you spread the cost into monthly EMIs of around ₹7,200, depending on the loan terms, so you can keep some money aside.
- Best Choice: Consider a mix of savings and a personal loan.
- Why: Using all your savings can make it difficult to manage your daily expenses if something unexpected happens. Using some savings and borrowing the rest may help you balance the cost with the need to keep money aside.
The right choice depends on how much savings you will have left, whether you can comfortably afford the EMI, and how urgent the expense is. Before taking a personal loan, check the interest rate, fees, total amount you will repay, and monthly EMI.
Personal Loan vs Fixed Deposit Withdrawal
If you have money saved in a Fixed Deposit (FD), you may wonder whether you should break it to cover an expense or take a Personal Loan instead.
To decide, compare the interest you would pay on the loan with the interest you would lose by withdrawing money from your FD early.
| Evaluation Factor | FD Premature Closure | Personal Loan | Overdraft / Loan Against FD |
| Typical Yield / Cost | Forfeits interest (6.5% – 7.5% p.a.) | Charges high interest (11.0% – 18.0% p.a.) | Charges 1.0% – 2.0% above FD rate (8.0% – 9.5%) |
| Associated Fees | Premature penalty (0.5% – 1.0% rate drop) | Processing fees (1%–3%) + Preclosure fees | Minimal setup fee; no prepayment penalty |
| Net Financial Impact | Modest loss of future interest earnings | High cumulative interest burden | Lowest net cost; preserves core deposit |
Disclaimer: Interest rates, processing fees, and charges for repaying your Personal Loan early may vary depending on the lender, your credit profile, and market conditions. These details may change over time. Please check the latest terms and charges with your lender or bank before making a decision.
Compare the Interest Rates
If your personal loan charges 14% interest and your FD earns 7%, you will pay more interest than you earn. Consider using your FD or taking a loan against FD at a lower rate (around 8.5%). Check any fees or penalties before deciding.
Quick Checklist Before You Decide
Before using your savings or taking a Personal Loan, ask yourself:
- Will I have less than 3 months of living expenses left in savings?
If yes, consider keeping some savings aside and borrowing only what you need.
- Is the loan interest higher than what my savings earn?
If yes, compare the cost of borrowing with the cost of using your savings.
- Will the new EMI make my monthly budget difficult to manage?
If yes, consider borrowing less or waiting.
- Is this expense urgent?
If not, consider saving up and paying for it later.
Choose a Personal Loan That Fits Your Budget
The right choice depends on your savings, monthly budget, and how urgent the expense is. Try to keep 3 to 6 months of living expenses aside for emergencies. If you need to borrow, compare the interest rate, fees, and total repayment amount before deciding.
If a personal loan makes sense for you, Use the Olyv app and compare personal loan options from RBI-registered lenders and pick a repayment plan that works for you.
